Editorial Policies and Roles

Animal Reports is managed by an academic editorial team consisting of the Editor-in-Chief, Senior Editors, Associate Editors, Editorial Board Members, and an Editorial Advisory Board. The Editorial Office and Copy Editor support the publication process but do not make scientific decisions.

Editors are expected to work fairly, independently, and within a reasonable time. They must follow the journals Peer Review Process, Research and Publication Ethics, and other published policies. Matters not covered by these policies will be considered in accordance with COPE guidance.

Quick links: Editorial independence | Decision-making | Appointments | Conflicts of interest | Confidentiality | Editors roles | Complaints and appeals

Editorial Independence▲

  • The Editor-in-Chief has authority over the journals editorial content and final decisions on manuscripts. The publisher provides administrative, technical, and production support but does not influence decisions on individual submissions.
  • Editorial decisions are based on the manuscript’s relevance to the journal, originality, scientific validity, clarity, and contribution to the field. Decisions are not influenced by the author’s nationality, institution, gender, personal beliefs, or the journals financial or promotional interests. The journals diamond open-access model and the absence of publication fees have no effect on editorial decisions.

Editorial Decision-Making▲

  • Research manuscripts are evaluated according to the journals published Peer Review Process. Each manuscript that proceeds to peer review is assessed by at least two independent external reviewers.
  • An Associate Editor may manage the review process and evaluate the reviewers reports and the authors revisions. The Associate Editor then provides a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief. Reviewers and Associate Editors provide advice, while the Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision.
  • When the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest, an independent Senior Editor assumes responsibility for the manuscript and makes the final decision.

Appointment and Terms of Service▲

  • Editors are selected according to their subject expertise, research and publication experience, professional conduct, and willingness to contribute to the journal. All editors must agree to their appointment and to the publication of their name and current affiliation on the journal website.
  • Editorial appointments are normally made for an initial two-year term and may be renewed according to the editor’s activity and the needs of the journal. Membership is reviewed periodically to ensure that the Editorial Team remains active, appropriately qualified, and relevant to the journals’ scope.
  • An editor may resign by informing the Editor-in-Chief. Membership may be ended in cases of continued inactivity, repeated failure to complete assigned work, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or serious breaches of the journals policies.
  • Editors may serve on the boards of other journals, but they should disclose relevant editorial positions and ensure that these commitments do not create conflicts of interest or prevent them from fulfilling their responsibilities to Animal Reports.

Conflicts of Interest▲

  • Editors must disclose any financial, institutional, professional, personal, or competitive interest that could affect, or reasonably appear to affect, their judgment.
  • An editor must not handle a manuscript involving an author from the same institution, a recent co-author or collaborator within the previous three years, a current or former supervisor or student, a close personal or family relationship, or a relevant financial or competitive interest. The manuscript will be reassigned to an independent editor.
  • Manuscripts submitted by the Editor-in-Chief, Senior Editors, Associate Editors, Editorial Board Members, or members of the Editorial Advisory Board are subject to the same editorial checks and external peer review as other submissions. The submitting editor or board member will not select reviewers, access confidential review information, or participate in the decision. A manuscript submitted by the Editor-in-Chief will be handled by an independent Senior Editor.

Confidentiality▲

  • Editors must keep manuscripts, reviewer identities, review reports, correspondence, and editorial discussions confidential. Information obtained during the editorial process must not be used for personal or professional advantage.
  • Editors must not upload manuscripts, reviews, or confidential information to external generative AI tools. Any approved automated tools may be used only for limited editorial checks and under human supervision, as described in the journals Research and Publication Ethics policy.

Editors Roles▲

Editor-in-Chief

The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for the journal’s scientific direction and editorial integrity. The main responsibilities are to:

  • Maintain the journals aim, scope, and editorial policies.
  • Conduct or oversee the initial assessment of submissions.
  • Assign manuscripts to qualified and independent editors.
  • Ensure that peer review is fair, confidential, and timely.
  • Make the final decision on manuscripts after considering the reviewers reports, the handling editors’ recommendations, and the authors responses.
  • Oversee ethical concerns, corrections, retractions, complaints, and appeals.
  • Appoint suitable editors and keep the Editorial Team active and up to date.

Senior Editors

Senior Editors support the Editor-in-Chief in matters requiring additional experience or independent oversight. They may:

  • Advise on complex scientific or publication-ethics cases.
  • Review appeals or complaints when they were not involved in the original decision.
  • Handle manuscripts when the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest.
  • Make the final decision on manuscripts formally assigned to them because of such a conflict.
  • Support the periodic review of editorial policies and board performance.

Associate Editors

Associate Editors manage manuscripts assigned to them within their areas of expertise. They do not make final decisions but submit reasoned recommendations to the Editor-in-Chief, who makes the final decision. Their responsibilities are to:

  • Conduct an initial scientific assessment of the assigned manuscript.
  • Identify and invite qualified, independent external reviewers.
  • Check potential conflicts of interest before assigning reviewers.
  • Monitor the review process and follow up on delayed reports.
  • Assess reviewers comments, revised manuscripts, and authors responses.
  • Provide the Editor-in-Chief with a clear recommendation to accept, revise, or reject the manuscript.
  • Maintain confidentiality and follow the journals ethical and peer-review policies.

Editorial Board Members

Editorial Board Members support the scientific quality and development of the journal. Their responsibilities may include:

  • Advising on the journal’s aims, scope, and editorial policies.
  • Identifying emerging research areas and suggesting topics for publication.
  • Recommending qualified researchers who may be considered as external reviewers.
  • Participating in discussions about the journal’s development and ethical practices.
  • Bringing potential ethical or scientific concerns to the attention of the Editor-in-Chief.
  • Supporting communication between the journal and the wider research community.

Editorial Board Members do not regularly conduct peer-review or decisions on individual manuscripts. In case one member is formally assigned to handle a manuscript, the responsibility and conflict-of-interest rules outlined for Associate Editors will apply. Membership does not automatically give access to manuscripts submitted or editorial information.

Editorial Advisory Board

The Editorial Advisory Board provides non-operational advice on the journal’s scientific direction and development. Advisory Board members do not normally manage peer review or make decisions on individual manuscripts. Its members may:

  • Advise on the journal’s aims, scope, and policies.
  • Identify emerging research areas and suggest topics for special issues.
  • Provide advice on difficult scientific or ethical matters when requested.
  • Support the journals academic visibility and connections with the research community.

Guest Editors

Special issues can be approved to have Guest Editors. They are subject to the journal's Special Issues Policy and can manage the peer-review process and make recommendations. The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for the process and final decision over all publication decisions. All manuscripts submitted by Guest Editors are handled independently.

Copy Editor and Editorial Office

The Copy Editor and Editorial Office work on manuscripts after editorial acceptance. They do not select reviewers, assess scientific merit, or influence acceptance and rejection decisions. Their responsibilities include:

  • Checking language, consistency, references, and journal style.
  • Preparing tables, figures, and page layout for publication.
  • Communicating proofs to authors and recording approved corrections.
  • Ensuring that required declarations and publication information are included.

Complaints and Appeals▲

Formal complaints and appeals are considered based on the journal's Research and Publication Ethics policy. An appeal is considered by an editor who did not participate in the initial decision. There is an independent editor to handle complaints regarding Editor-in-Chief.

 

Updated: 10 August 2026